Ashley Howe’s Analysis of Tooth Crowding

Introduction

Today, we will discuss Ashley Howe’s analysis, which provides valuable insights into the causes of tooth crowding and the relationship between dental arch dimensions and tooth size. Howe’s work emphasizes the importance of arch width over arch length in understanding dental crowding.

Key Concepts

Tooth Crowding

• Definition: Tooth crowding refers to the lack of space in the dental arch for all teeth to fit properly.
• Howe’s Perspective: Howe posited that tooth crowding is primarily due to a deficiency in arch width rather than arch length.

Relationship Between Tooth Size and Arch Width

• Howe identified a significant relationship between the total mesiodistal diameter of teeth anterior to the second permanent molar and the width of the dental arch in the first premolar region. This relationship is crucial for understanding how tooth size can impact arch dimensions and overall dental alignment.

Procedure for Analysis

To conduct Ashley Howe’s analysis, the following measurements must be obtained:

1. Percentage of PMD to TTM
   PMD X 100
         TTM
2. Percentage of PMBAW to TTM
   PMBAW X 100
       TTM

3. Percentage of BAL to TTM: [ \text{Percentage of BAL} = \left( \frac{\text{BAL}}{\text{TTM}} \right) \times 100 ]

Where:

• PMD = Total mesiodistal diameter of teeth anterior to the second permanent molar.
• PMBAW = Premolar basal arch width.
• BAL = Basal arch length.
• TTM = Total tooth mesiodistal measurement.

Inferences from the Analysis

The results of the measurements can lead to several important inferences regarding treatment options for tooth crowding:

1. If PMBAW > PMD:

   • This indicates that the basal arch is sufficient to allow for the expansion of the premolars. In this case, expansion may be a viable treatment option.

2. If PMD > PMBAW:

   • This scenario can lead to three possible treatment options:
     1. Contraindicated for Expansion: Expansion may not be advisable.
     2. Move Teeth Distally: Consideration for distal movement of teeth to create space.
     3. Extract Some Teeth: Extraction may be necessary to alleviate crowding.

3. If PMBAW X 100 / TTM:

   • Less than 37%: Extraction is likely required.
   • 44%: This is considered an ideal case where extraction is not necessary.
   • Between 37% and 44%: This is a borderline case where extraction may or may not be required, necessitating further evaluation.

SEQUENCE OF ERUPTION OF DECIDUOUS TEETH

Upper/Lower   A B D C E 

SEQUENCE OF ERUPTION OF PERMAMENT TEETH 

Upper:   6 1 2 4 3 5 7           Lower:    6 1 2 3 4 5 7   
      
or       6 1 2 4 5 3 7              or  6 1 2 4 3 5 7 
 

ANTHROPOID SPACE / PRIMATE SPACE / SIMIEN’S SPACE  

The space mesial to upper deciduous canine and distal to lower deciduous  canine is characteristically found in primates and hence it is called primate space.  

INCISOR LIABILITY 

When the permanent central incisor erupt, these teeth use up specially all the spaces found in the normal dentition. With the eruption of permanent lateral incisor the space situation becomes tight. In the maxillary arch it is just enough to accommodate but in mandibular arch there is an average 1.6 mm less space available. This difference between the space present and space required is known as incisor liability. 
These conditions overcome by;  

      1. This is a transient condition and extra space comes from slight increase in arch width.   
      2. Slight labial positioning of central and lateral incisor. 
      3. Distal shift of permanent canine.        

      
LEE WAY SPACE (OF NANCE)  

The combined mesiodistal width of the permanent canines and pre molars is usually less that of the deciduous canines and molars. This space is 
called leeway space of Nance.     

Measurement of lee way space: 
 
Is greater in the mandibular arch than in the maxillary arch  It is about 1.8mm [0.9mm on each side of the arch] in the maxillary arch. 
And about 3.4mm [1.7 mm on side of the arch] in the mandibular arch. 
 
Importance:  

 This lee way space allows the mesial movement of lower molar there by correcting flush terminal plane.     
 LWS can be measure with the help of cephalometry.    

FLUSH TERMINAL PLANE (TERMINAL PLANE RELATIONSHIP) 

Mandibular 2nd deciduous molar is usually wider mesio-distally then the maxillary 2nd deciduous molar. This leads to the development of flush terminal plane which falls along the distal surface of upper and lower 2nd deciduous molar. This develops into class I molar relationship. 

Distal step relationship leads to class 2 relationship.
Mesial step relationship mostly leads to class 3 relationship.  

FEATURE OF IDEAL OCCLUSION IN PRIMARY DENTITION 

1. Spacing of anterior teeth. 
2. Primate space is present. 
3. Flush terminal plane is found. 
4. Almost vertical inclination of anterior teeth. 
5. Overbite and overjet varies.  

UGLY DUCKLING STAGE  

Definition:  
Stage of a transient or self correcting malocclusion is seen sometimes is called ugly duck ling stage. 
 
Occurring site: Maxillary incisor region 

Occuring age: 8-9 years of age.  

This situation is seen during the eruption of the permanent canines. As the developing p.c. they displace the roots of lateral incisor mesially this results is transmitting of the force on to the roots of the central incisors which also gets displaced mesially. A resultant distal divergence of the crowns of the two central incisors causes midline spacing.  

This portion of teeth at this stage is compared to that of ugly walk of the duckling and hence it is called Ugly Duckling Stage. 

Described by Broad bent. In this stage children tend to look ugly. Parents are often apprehensive during this stage and consult the dentist.  

Corrects by itself, when canines erupt and the pressure is transferred from the roots to the coronal area of the incisor.  
IMPORTANCE OF 1ST MOLAR
 
1. It is the key tooth to occlusion. 
2.  Angle’s classification is based on this tooth. 
3.  It is the tooth of choice for anchorage. 
4.  Supports occlusion in a vertical direction. 
5.  Loss of this tooth leads to migration of other tooth. 
6.  Helps in opening the bite.   

Anterior Crossbite

Anterior crossbite is a dental condition where one or more of the upper front teeth (maxillary incisors) are positioned behind the lower front teeth (mandibular incisors) when the jaws are closed. This misalignment can lead to functional issues, aesthetic concerns, and potential wear on the teeth. Correcting anterior crossbite is essential for achieving proper occlusion and improving overall dental health.

Methods to Correct Anterior Crossbite

1. Acrylic Incline Plane:

   • Description: An acrylic incline plane is a removable appliance that can be used to guide the movement of the teeth. It is designed to create a ramp-like surface that encourages the maxillary incisors to move forward.
   • Mechanism: The incline plane helps to reposition the maxillary teeth by providing a surface that directs the teeth into a more favorable position during function.

2. Reverse Stainless Steel Crown:

   • Description: A reverse stainless steel crown can be used in cases where the anterior teeth are significantly misaligned. This crown is designed to provide a stable and durable solution for correcting the crossbite.
   • Mechanism: The crown can be adjusted to help reposition the maxillary teeth, allowing them to move into a more normal relationship with the mandibular teeth.

3. Hawley Retainer with Recurve Springs:

   • Description: A Hawley retainer is a removable orthodontic appliance that can be modified with recurve springs to correct anterior crossbite.
   • Mechanism: The recurve springs apply gentle pressure to the maxillary incisors, tipping them forward into a more favorable position relative to the mandibular teeth. This appliance is comfortable, easily retained, and predictable in its effects.

4. Fixed Labial-Lingual Appliance:

   • Description: A fixed labial-lingual appliance is a type of orthodontic device that is bonded to the teeth and can be used to correct crossbites.
   • Mechanism: This appliance works by applying continuous forces to the maxillary teeth, tipping them forward and correcting the crossbite. It may include a vertical removable arch for ease of adjustment and recurve springs to facilitate movement.

5. Vertical Removable Arch:

   • Description: This appliance can be used in conjunction with other devices to provide additional support and adjustment capabilities.
   • Mechanism: The vertical removable arch allows for easy modifications and adjustments, helping to jump the crossbite by repositioning the maxillary teeth.

Bruxism

Bruxism is the involuntary grinding or clenching of teeth, often occurring during sleep (nocturnal bruxism) or while awake (awake bruxism). It can lead to various dental and health issues, including tooth wear, jaw pain, and temporomandibular joint (TMJ) disorders.

Etiology

1. Central Nervous System (CNS):

   • Bruxism has been observed in individuals with neurological conditions such as cerebral palsy and mental retardation, suggesting a CNS component to the phenomenon.

2. Psychological Factors:

   • Emotional disturbances such as anxiety, stress, aggression, and feelings of hunger can contribute to the tendency to grind teeth. Psychological stressors are often linked to increased muscle tension and bruxism.

3. Occlusal Discrepancy:

   • Improper interdigitation of teeth, such as malocclusion or misalignment, can lead to bruxism as the body attempts to find a comfortable bite.

4. Systemic Factors:

   • Nutritional deficiencies, particularly magnesium (Mg²⁺) deficiency, have been associated with bruxism. Magnesium plays a role in muscle function and relaxation.

5. Genetic Factors:

   • There may be a hereditary component to bruxism, with a family history of the condition increasing the likelihood of its occurrence.

6. Occupational Factors:

   • High-stress occupations or activities, such as being an overenthusiastic student or participating in competitive sports, can lead to increased clenching and grinding of teeth.

Clinical Features

• Tooth Wear: Increased wear on the occlusal surfaces of teeth, leading to flattened or worn-down teeth.
• Jaw Pain: Discomfort or pain in the jaw muscles, particularly in the masseter and temporalis muscles.
• TMJ Disorders: Symptoms such as clicking, popping, or locking of the jaw, as well as pain in the TMJ area.
• Headaches: Tension-type headaches or migraines may occur due to muscle tension associated with bruxism.
• Facial Pain: Generalized facial pain or discomfort, particularly around the jaw and temples.
• Gum Recession: Increased risk of gum recession and periodontal issues due to excessive force on the teeth.

Management

1. Adjunctive Therapy:

   • Psychotherapy: Aimed at reducing emotional disturbances and stress that may contribute to bruxism. Techniques may include cognitive-behavioral therapy (CBT) or relaxation techniques.
   • Pain Management:
     • Ethyl Chloride: A topical anesthetic that can be injected into the TMJ area to alleviate pain and discomfort.

2. Occlusal Therapy:

   • Occlusal Adjustment: Adjusting the occlusion to improve the bite and reduce bruxism.
   • Splints:
     • Volcanite Splints: These are custom-made occlusal splints that cover the occlusal surfaces of all teeth. They help reduce muscle tone and protect the teeth from wear.
     • Night Guards: Similar to splints, night guards are worn during sleep to prevent grinding and clenching.
   • Restorative Treatment: Addressing any existing dental issues, such as cavities or misaligned teeth, to improve overall dental health.

3. Pharmacological Management:

   • Vapo Coolant: Ethyl chloride can be used for pain relief in the TMJ area.
   • Local Anesthesia: Direct injection of local anesthetics into the TMJ can provide temporary relief from pain.
   • Muscle Relaxants: Medications such as muscle tranquilizers or sedatives may be prescribed to help reduce muscle tension and promote relaxation.

Catalan's Appliance

Catalan's appliance, also known as the Catalan appliance or lower inclined bite plane, is an orthodontic device primarily used to correct anterior crossbites and manage dental arch relationships. It is particularly effective in growing children and adolescents, as it helps to guide the development of the dental arches and improve occlusion.

Indications for Use

1. Anterior Crossbite:

   • The primary indication for Catalan's appliance is to correct anterior crossbites, where the upper front teeth are positioned behind the lower front teeth when the jaws are closed.

2. Space Management:

   • It can be used to create space in the dental arch, especially when there is crowding or insufficient space for the eruption of permanent teeth.

3. Guiding Eruption:

   • The appliance helps guide the eruption of the permanent teeth into a more favorable position, promoting proper alignment.

4. Facilitating Growth:

   • It can assist in the growth of the maxilla and mandible, helping to achieve a more balanced facial profile.

Design and Features

• Components:

  • The Catalan's appliance typically consists of:
    • Acrylic Base: A custom-fitted acrylic base that covers the lower anterior teeth.
    • Inclined Plane: An inclined plane is incorporated into the appliance, which helps to reposition the anterior teeth by providing a surface for the teeth to occlude against.
    • Retention Mechanism: The appliance is retained in the mouth using clasps or other anchorage methods to ensure stability during treatment.

• Customization:

  • The appliance is custom-made for each patient based on their specific dental anatomy and treatment needs. This ensures a proper fit and effective function.

Mechanism of Action

• Correction of Crossbite:

  • The inclined plane of the Catalan's appliance exerts forces on the anterior teeth, encouraging them to move into a more favorable position. This helps to correct the crossbite by allowing the maxillary incisors to move forward relative to the mandibular incisors.

• Space Creation:

  • By repositioning the anterior teeth, the appliance can create additional space in the dental arch, facilitating the eruption of permanent teeth and improving overall alignment.

• Guiding Eruption:

  • The appliance helps guide the eruption of the permanent teeth by maintaining proper arch form and preventing unwanted movements of the teeth.

Angle's Classification of Malocclusion

Developed by Dr. Edward Angle in the early 20th century, this classification is based on the relationship of the first molars and the canines. It is divided into three main classes:

Class I Malocclusion (Normal Occlusion)

• Description: The first molars are in a normal relationship, with the mesiobuccal cusp of the maxillary first molar fitting into the buccal groove of the mandibular first molar. The canines also have a normal relationship.
• Characteristics:
  • The dental arches are aligned.
  • There may be crowding, spacing, or other dental irregularities, but the overall molar relationship is normal.

Class II Malocclusion (Distocclusion)

• Description: The first molars are positioned such that the mesiobuccal cusp of the maxillary first molar is positioned more than one cusp width ahead of the buccal groove of the mandibular first molar.
• Subdivisions:
  • Class II Division 1: Characterized by protruded maxillary incisors and a deep overbite.
  • Class II Division 2: Characterized by retroclined maxillary incisors and a deep overbite, often with a normal or reduced overjet.
• Characteristics: This class often results in an overbite and can lead to aesthetic concerns.

Class III Malocclusion (Mesioocclusion)

• Description: The first molars are positioned such that the mesiobuccal cusp of the maxillary first molar is positioned more than one cusp width behind the buccal groove of the mandibular first molar.
• Characteristics:
  • This class is often associated with an underbite, where the lower teeth are positioned more forward than the upper teeth.
  • It can lead to functional issues and aesthetic concerns.

2. Skeletal Classification

In addition to Angle's classification, malocclusion can also be classified based on skeletal relationships, which consider the position of the maxilla and mandible in relation to each other. This classification is particularly useful in assessing the underlying skeletal discrepancies that may contribute to malocclusion.

Class I Skeletal Relationship

• Description: The maxilla and mandible are in a normal relationship, similar to Class I malocclusion in Angle's classification.
• Characteristics: The skeletal bases are well-aligned, but there may still be dental irregularities.

Class II Skeletal Relationship

• Description: The mandible is positioned further back relative to the maxilla, similar to Class II malocclusion.
• Characteristics: This can be due to a retruded mandible or an overdeveloped maxilla.

Class III Skeletal Relationship

• Description: The mandible is positioned further forward relative to the maxilla, similar to Class III malocclusion.
• Characteristics: This can be due to a protruded mandible or a retruded maxilla.

3. Other Classifications

In addition to Angle's and skeletal classifications, malocclusion can also be described based on specific characteristics:

• Overbite: The vertical overlap of the upper incisors over the lower incisors. It can be classified as:

  • Normal Overbite: Approximately 1-2 mm of overlap.
  • Deep Overbite: Excessive overlap, which can lead to impaction of the lower incisors.
  • Open Bite: Lack of vertical overlap, where the upper and lower incisors do not touch.

• Overjet: The horizontal distance between the labioincisal edge of the upper incisors and the linguoincisal edge of the lower incisors. It can be classified as:

  • Normal Overjet: Approximately 2-4 mm.
  • Increased Overjet: Greater than 4 mm, often associated with Class II malocclusion.
  • Decreased Overjet: Less than 2 mm, often associated with Class III malocclusion.

• Crossbite: A condition where one or more of the upper teeth bite on the inside of the lower teeth. It can be:

  • Anterior Crossbite: Involves the front teeth.
  • Posterior Crossbite: Involves the back teeth.